top of page

Home / Blogs /

Monarch Money vs. YNAB: Which Budgeting Tool is Right for You?

Monarch Money vs. YNAB: Which Budgeting Tool is Right for You?

July 23, 2020

7

minutes

Monarch Money Vs YNAB:


Monarch Money vs YNAB
Monarch Money vs YNAB

The secret to your financial success lies in effective budgeting, in which a great budgeting app can be your companion in achieving it. In today's world, choosing the right financial tool can be difficult, leading them to make mistakes in their selection. 


That's why we have brought you a detailed comparison of the top two leading apps, “Monarch Money and YNAB (You Need A Budget),”  in the finance market. This detailed feature breakdown will provide details on both apps and help you make an informed decision.



An In-Depth Look at Monarch Money

Monarch Money Review
Monarch Money Review

Monarch Money is known because of its smooth user experience and amazing features. It's accessible to everyone due to its simplistic design and seamless service, from categorizing to automatically monitoring transactions. Additionally, it reminds you of your spending habits without requiring manual effort. 


It assists you in tracking your net worth goals and other expenses, helping you monitor your financial goals. It also stands out with its set of financial planning tools specifically designed for retirement purposes.


Furthermore, Monarch Money makes it easy to connect with your different bank accounts and financial services, which allows you to manage all your money in one place without having to log into multiple websites or apps. This makes organizing your finances much simpler and less stressful.


Monarch Money offers personalized financial advice to people who need it. You can work with a financial counselor to get recommendations tailored to your unique financial situation.



Monarch Money: Pricing, Pros, and Cons


Monarch Money's pricing is straightforward and includes all the essential features for budgeting. 


However, it's important to consider all factors before choosing this software.


Pros:

  • Comprehensive financial planning tools

  • Automatic transaction categorization

  • Access to financial advisors (optional)

Cons:

  • Limited customization options

  • It may be overwhelming for budgeting beginners


Monarch Money is perfect for people who want a complete budgeting app to manage their finances automatically because it comes with a range of functionalities and an option to have professional advice in place, which ultimately helps you manage your finances.


A real-life example:

David, a small business owner, appreciated how Monarch Money's integration with his business accounts simplified his financial management.



Delving into YNAB (You Need A Budget)

YNAB Review
YNAB Review

YNAB is based on a zero-based budgeting system, which means that every dollar has its own value. It shows users where every dollar of their hard-earned money is spent. YNAB works to help users achieve their financial goals through this zero-based budgeting system. 


In this way, users know where each dollar can be saved, which helps them to make better financial decisions for the future.YNAB also offers you a real-time budget tracking feature, allowing you to track and adjust your budget simultaneously. 


Additionally, you can create custom categories and even set reminders, utilize reports and other tools that fulfill your personal budget requirements, and help you make your budgeting management much better.


YNAB also provides you with a strong emphasis on education and community support as it offers countless blogs, webinars, and forums for users to maintain their interest and continue learning about budgeting processes. This enables you to improve your budgeting skills and avoid any financial stress.


YNAB: Pricing, Pros, and Cons

When making a decision, it's helpful to know the pros and cons of YNAB's pricing structure.


Pros:

  • Zero-based budgeting methodology

  • Real-time budget adjustments

  • Strong educational resources and community support

Cons:

  • Requires manual transaction entry

  • The steeper learning curve for budgeting newcomers



YNAB is ideal for those who want a realistic and effective way to handle their finances and want to utilize features like zero-based budgeting, which helps them manage their hard-earned money even better. 



A real-life example: 


"Maria, a recent graduate, loved how YNAB's educational resources empowered her to take control of her finances and build a solid financial foundation."



Comparing Monarch Money and YNAB: Key Differences


Both Monarch Money and YNAB have similar purposes: to help people achieve their financial goals in the best way possible. However, there are some key differences in how they manage your budgets. Each tool comes with its own methods of budgeting and unique features that help people track their finances. Both these financial tools provide a great overall experience, making it easier for users to manage their finances with ease.


If you want to select the best financial app, you first need to consider your financial objectives and goals. First of all, determine how you want to manage your finances, what features you need, and which app offers those features.


Therefore, carefully examine their tools and other features, and thoroughly read their pricing and other sections to determine which app stands out as the best for your finances. It's also important to choose the tool that offers the best features at a lower cost.


Feature table for Monarch Money vs YNAB:

Feature

Monarch Money

YNAB

Envelope Budgeting

Goal Tracking

Debt Management

Investment Tracking

Bill Payment Reminders

Spending Reports

Free Version Available

Mobile App

Cryptocurrency Support

Multi-Currency Support

Integrated Credit Score Tracking




How to Choose the Right Budgeting Tool for Your Needs


This guide will help you select the best budgeting tool that aligns with the features you're interested in and your financial goals. 



Identify Your Preferred Budgeting Style and Features

First, consider how much control you want over your budget. Monarch Money may seem more attractive if you prefer an automatic and simplified budgeting approach. However, if you want greater control and involvement in your finances, then YNAB, which comes with a zero-based budget, might be a better fit for you.


Consider the Importance of Financial Advice and Educational Resources

If budgeting advice and educational materials are important to you, then you should consider Monarch Money because it offers non-mandatory advice when you're planning your finances. 


However, YNAB also provides excellent educational materials through its blogs and various resources, such as webinars and a secure community that helps you improve your budgeting over time.


Evaluate Pricing and Value for Money

Ultimately, choose between Monarch Money and YNAB, keeping in mind which gives you more for your money. Keep in mind that the least expensive option might not always be the best fit for you, so consider the balance between price and features when deciding between these two tools.



Choosing the Right Tool for You: A Personalized Approach

Different ways of budgeting and different money goals need different tools.


Let's dive into which platform might be the perfect fit for you:


For Beginners:

Suppose you're a beginner or want automated financial management. In that case, Monarch Money is an excellent choice for you because it offers automatic transaction and categorization, which helps you monitor your spending without constantly worrying about your finances. 


Additionally, it has a user-friendly interface that provides an easy starting point for newbies. This app also offers financial consultations and advice to start your financial journey.


However, if you're a beginner looking for educational material for learning finances, consider a YNAB, which comes with a vast collection of resources like numerous articles, webinars, and communities on budgeting basics. This will help you learn how to manage and track your budget from the start.


For Experienced Budgeters:

If you're an experienced budgeter who wants to continuously track your spending, know where every dollar is spent, and find different ways to save it, then YNAB might be the best choice for you. 


It offers a higher level of customization and provides insights into where your money is being spent and where it should be invested, which allows you to manage your finances and maintain full control of them effectively. You can also create customizable categories and reports tailored to your financial goals, helping you optimize them.


However, if you're an expert budgeter, Monarch Money could also be beneficial due to its investment tracking and requirement features. By utilizing its advanced features, you can gain valuable insights. Ultimately, the choice between the two apps depends on your individual preferences and needs.


For Hands-Off Budgeters:

If you believe in a "set it and forget it" method, Monarch money is perfect for you. Its automated features will manage your finances effectively, regardless of whether you actively engage with it or not. It automatically tracks your finances and helps you achieve your financial goals while also facilitating financial improvements. Thanks to its clean, easy-to-use, and user-friendly interface, which is easy to navigate and use.


For Hands-On Budgeters:

If you're someone who desires a high level of customization for your finances, you should look for YNAB. This financial app provides you with detailed information about your spending habits, which means where your money is spent and where you can save for the future. Additionally, it helps you track your spending and budgeting, and its manual transaction feature allows you to monitor your expenses closely. It also offers customizable budgets based on your personal preferences and financial goals.


Both of these apps, Monarch Money and YNAB, cover your budgeting spectrum well, so whether you select either of them, depending on your preference, both will give you the best budgeting experience.



Real-life financial situations:


Monarch Money:


  • The Smiths, a family saving for a down payment: "The Smiths, a family of four, were determined to save for a down payment on their dream home. Monarch Money's net worth tracking feature allowed them to visualize their progress and stay motivated, while the goal-setting tools helped them create a realistic savings plan and track their spending against it."

YNAB:

  • The Johnsons, a couple on a tight budget: "The Johnsons, a young couple with student loan debt and a limited income, found YNAB's zero-based budgeting method to be a game-changer. By giving every dollar a job, they were able to prioritize their spending, pay off their debt faster, and still enjoy the occasional night out."


Conclusion


Monarch Money vs YNAB both are a great options for your budget management that help you succeed financially and fulfill your financial goals. They provide financial advice and educational materials, teaching you how to learn and manage your finances effectively. Whether you are a beginner or a budgeting expert, both of these tools can help you control your finances and make every possible effort to improve them. 








Monarch Money vs. YNAB: Which Budgeting Tool is Right for You?

Join our email list and get access to specials deals exclusive to our subscribers.

THE SAVING DUDE

©2024 by The Saving Dude

bottom of page